Planet Swank banner
Planet Swank
us flag courtesy south knox bubba
about me
my résumé (pdf)
email me
wish list

 

Favorite posts
halloween 2003 roundup (coming soon)
halloween 2002 roundup
the future of online gaming
star wars cereal review
japanese culture link of the day (12/6/2002)
japanese culture link of the day (12/23/2002)
reviews: hentai games sux0rz
anime term of the day (fan service, 02/17/2003)
retro gaming link of the day (battletech)
20 favorite movies since 1980
second japanese culture link of the day (11/20/2003)
 

Recent posts at Destroy All Monsters
Check out today's news posts at Destroy All Monsters
 


Recommended:
destroy all monsters
megatokyo
sinfest
8-bit theatre
the onion
mac hall
penny arcade
twisted kaiju theater
this modern world
dilbert
giant robot
8bit joystick
retrolounge
teleport city
stomp tokyo
cold fusion video reviews
kung fu cinema
anime web turnpike
random abstract
radio paradise
neil gaiman
william gibson
greg costikyan
xeni jardin
nasa's astronomy picture of the day
techrepublic
u.s. constitution
the democratic party's blog
indiana democratic party
center for american progress
donkey rising
tompaine.com
fark
boing boing
metafilter
kuro5hin
the hoosier review
misleader
spinsanity
the daily howler
this modern world
the joe bob report
gamespot
quake 2
 

Blogs:
nextblog (random)
blogdex
memeorandum
daypop
the truth laid bear
technorati
the lefty directory
indiana blogs

#!-usr-bin-girl
alas, a blog
altercation
andrew hagen
angry bear
annatopia
asymmetrical information
bertrand russel
blah3
blog left
blog of the moderate left
blue streak
body and soul
bookslut
brut4c
busy, busy, busy
byzantium's shores
calpundit
charles murtaugh
chris c. mooney
collaboratory
confessions of a g33k
cooped up
corrente
counterspin central
critiques of editorials
crooked timber
cut on the bias
daily kos
daniel drezner
demagogue
democratic veteran
destroy all blogs
die puny humans
d-squared digest
electrolite
eschaton
etched in stone
fester's place
flit
founding issues
geisha asobi blog
gorilla-a-go-go
how appealing
hullabaloo
insanekungfu
intel dump
interesting times
ipse dixit
it's still the economy, stupid
jack o'toole
juan cole
kieran healy
late night thoughts
legal fiction
lillianchan
long story, short pier
making light
mark byron
mark a. r. kleiman
matt welch
matthew yglesias
meryl yourish
min jung kim
modulator
monkeywatch
mydd
nathan newman
never trust a monkey
nitpicker
no more mister nice blog
notes on the atrocities
not geniuses
off the kuff
oliver willis
oni blogger
onye's livejournal
open source politics
orcinus
pacific views
pandagon
peevish
pharyngula
philosoraptor
p.l.a.
political aims
political animal
political wire
quaker in a basement
reachm high
roger ailes
royal blue
ruminate this
rungu
sadly, no!
scoobie davis
seeing the forest
self made pundit
semi-daily journal (brad delong)
shadow of the hegemon
sisyphus shrugged
sixdifferentways
slacktivist
skeptical notion
skippy the bush kangaroo
south knox bubba
swanky conservative
tacitus
talking points memo
talkleft
tapped
tbogg
terminus
testify!
the 18 minute gap
the adventures of accordionguy in the 21st century
the agonist
the american street
the avocado couch
the blog of chloë and pete
the campaign desk
the gadflyer
the gamer's nook
the left coaster
the light of reason
the peking duck
the people's republic of seabrook
the poor man
the power pill
the right christians
the rittenhouse review
the road to surfdom
the sideshow
the talking dog
the volokh conspiracy
thinking it through
through the looking glass
to the barricades!
to the point
tristero
uggabugga
unmedia
unqualified offerings
very big blog
very very happy
wampumblog
warliberal
whatever
whiskey bar
wiley wiggins
wil wheaton
wonkette
worldgonewrong
 

Archives:


-- HOME --


L337 lexicon
...speak l337?
(image courtesy megatokyo)
L33t/l33+: elite
b33r: beer
h4x0r: hacker
j00: you
L4m3: lame
L33t: elite
ph33r: fear
sux0rz: sucks
sw33t: sweet
w00t: woo hoo!
download a l33+ 5p34k generator here

Site Feed

link to me
link to me



background image courtesy pixeldecor

random quote javascript provided by
javascript kit



indianapolis weather:
The WeatherPixie
Google
This page is powered by Blogger. Why isn't yours?
  xThursday, June 27, 2002

taking the pledge


By now it's all over the blogosphere that a three-member panel of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled the required recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance in public schools unconstitutional due to the 1954 addition of the words "under God." Predictably, editorial boards, senators, and not a few ordinary citizens are outraged by the ruling.

I don't have any comment on the legal basis of the ruling; The Volkoh Conspiracy has much thoughtful analysis (start there and work your way up). His take as I understand it: "a perfectly plausible application of the Supreme Court's precedents on the matter," but by no means sure to survive--or fail under--a Supreme Court test.

I do, however, have a comment on the issue that I haven't seen made elsewhere yet. Does anyone other than schoolkids and people granted U.S. citizenship ever say the Pledge of Allegiance? Think about the idea of a pledge...my Webster's defines it as "a binding promise or agreement to do or forbear" (and also as "a bailment of a chattel as security for a debt or other obligation," but that one doesn't apply). But minors can't legally be held to a contract; they're assumed to not be sufficiently responsible to be held to their word. In that light, of course the Pledge is coercive...it's asking a promise of someone assumed not to be able to assume responsibility for the promise. The idea, I'm pretty sure, is to have the recitiation of the Pledge instill the values if espouses by rote repetition--not that that's an inherently bad thing, but I don't think it's unreasonable to hold the phrase "under God" to a more stringent test than other examples of "ceremonial Deism" like the "in God we trust" motto on currency.

Also, the notion that someone could "voluntarily" refrain from taking part in the Pledge (or so-called "voluntary" prayers) doesn't wash with me. There's tremendous pressure in schools to conform--at least as I remember school. The problem with the concept of "voluntary" is that it endorses a display of "we all believe this, and you're an outsider for not believeing as we do," It establishes a preference for one belief system over another. That for me is enough to consider applying the First Amendment's Establishment clause.

I'm cooking up some more thoughts and hope to post them later.

Update: One of the judges who issued the ruling--a Nixon appointee, by the way--has issued a stay pending appeal, so it looks like whatever the brouhaha, nothing will change until the Supreme Court has a chance to weigh in on the matter.